Lancaster Pie & Coffee

About Lancaster Pie & Coffee

Lancaster Pie & Coffee is a bakery and cafe located at 136 N Prince St in Lancaster, PA. They specialize in scratch-made sweet and savory pies, waffles, and coffee beverages. The establishment emphasizes using quality ingredients and a homemade approach to their baking, aiming to provide comforting and delicious treats. Reviewers frequently highlight the flaky crusts and flavorful fillings of their pies, as well as the friendly and welcoming atmosphere. They offer a variety of pie sizes, including slices, hand pies, and larger whole pies for special orders.

The Vibe

This establishment offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, often described as feeling like a visit to a grandparent's home. The space is intimate, with limited seating that contributes to a warm, communal feel. Staff members are consistently noted for their exceptional friendliness, engaging with customers and creating a personable experience. It's a place where both the food and the interactions with the team leave a positive impression, making it a comfortable spot for a casual treat or a brief respite.

• cozy
• friendly
• welcoming
• charming

What's Good

• Bourbon Pecan Pie

  Praised for its rich flavor and perfectly executed crust, this pie is frequently cited as a standout item.

• Brisket Hand Pie

  $7.00

  A savory option featuring a flaky crust and a well-seasoned, hearty brisket filling, popular for lunch or a snack.

• Liege Waffle

  Described as caramelized yet soft, these waffles are a popular choice, especially when topped with fruit and cream.

• Sour Cherry Hand Pie

  Features natural fruit flavor with just the right amount of sweetness and a sturdy, flaky crust.

• Chocolate Silk Pie

  $3.50

  Consistently receives high praise for its decadent texture and rich flavor, often compared to homemade versions.

Perfect For

• casual dining
• dessert spot
• coffee break
• quick bite