Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant

About Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant

Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant is an Italian eatery located at 401 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY. The restaurant offers a range of Italian-American comfort food, with a particular focus on pizza. Reviews highlight the quality of the crust and sauce on their pizzas, including specialty options like the Buffalo Chicken slice. Beyond pizza, the menu includes pasta dishes, chicken entrees, and seafood. The establishment is noted for its casual atmosphere and family-friendly environment, making it a local gathering spot on Staten Island.

The Vibe

Cafe Milano presents a casual and family-friendly atmosphere, often described as a neighborhood staple. The service is generally noted as friendly and efficient, contributing to a comfortable dining experience. While not a formal setting, it's a place where locals gather for familiar Italian-American dishes. Some reviews mention a lack of pretense, focusing on the food and a welcoming environment. It serves as a reliable option for both dine-in and takeout.

• casual
• family friendly
• neighborhood
• cozy

What's Good

• Buffalo Chicken slice

  A surprisingly delicious specialty pizza slice balancing tangy heat and creamy texture, noted for its excellent crust and sauce.

• Chicken Marsala

  $18.95

  Pan-seared chicken served with a Marsala wine sauce and mushrooms, with a choice of side.

• Eggplant Parmigiana

  A highly-rated dish, praised for its excellent preparation and generous portion size.

• Tiramisu

  $5.50

  A classic Italian dessert made with coffee-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cheese.

• Grandma pie

  A well-regarded pizza option, noted for its delicious taste and excellent undercarriage.

Perfect For

• casual dining
• family meal
• takeout