Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Colleyville

About Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Colleyville

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Colleyville, TX, is a locally-owned dessert shop specializing in handmade pies. They offer pies in various sizes, including 4-inch and 9-inch options, as well as a "Stack of 4 Mini-Pies" for sampling. Popular flavors include Apple, Key Lime, Pecan, and Chocolate Cream. The shop emphasizes community and sharing, aiming to provide a welcoming atmosphere for conversation over delicious food. They are known for their buttery crusts and flavorful fillings, with a health score of 96.

The Vibe

This pie shop cultivates a community-focused and cozy atmosphere, encouraging guests to gather and share. The service is often described as friendly and accommodating, with staff maintaining smiles even when busy. While it's a small space, the focus is on the quality of the pies. It's a place where the emphasis is on enjoying a sweet treat and good conversation, making it suitable for quick visits or casual gatherings.

• casual
• family friendly
• community focused
• cozy

What's Good

• 4” Apple

  $11.05

  Features crisp Granny Smith apples with sugar and spice, packed into a buttery crust and topped with house-made apple crumble.

• 9" Apple

  $41.60

  A larger version of the popular apple pie, made with crisp Granny Smith apples and a buttery crust.

• 4” Key Lime

  $11.05

  A tart and refreshing pie option, noted by reviewers as a standout even when craving other flavors.

• 9" Pecan

  $41.60

  A classic pecan pie, praised for its sweet but not overly sweet flavor and plentiful crunchy pecans.

• Stack Of 4 Mini-Pies

  $28.60

  Allows for mixing and matching of mini-pie flavors, perfect for sampling or gifting.

Perfect For

• casual dining
• dessert
• celebration
• quick bite