Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Arlington

About Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Arlington

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Arlington, TX, offers a variety of sweet treats with a focus on pies. They provide full-sized pies and personal-sized options, making them suitable for individual enjoyment or sharing. The shop is known for its classic and seasonal pie flavors, with options like Nanny's Pecan, Key Lime, and I-40 being popular choices. They also offer gluten-free options for some of their pies. The establishment is a to-go focused bakery, emphasizing convenient pick-up and delivery services for customers seeking homemade-style pies.

The Vibe

This pie shop operates primarily as a to-go establishment with limited or no indoor seating. The atmosphere is generally described as friendly and welcoming, with staff often noted for their helpfulness in guiding customers through the pie selections. While not a place for lingering, the focus is on providing quality pies efficiently. It's a spot for those seeking a sweet treat to enjoy elsewhere, whether at home or a gathering.

• casual
• cozy
• friendly

What's Good

• Nanny's Pecan

  $34.50

  A Southern favorite featuring toasted pecans and a gooey filling within a buttery shortbread crust, recognized for its balanced sweetness and pecan-to-filling ratio.

• I-40

  $34.50

  A popular twist on pecan pie, this offering combines pecans, chocolate chips, and coconut in a shortbread crust, baked to perfection.

• Key Lime

  $34.50

  Made with a house-made graham cracker crust, this pie features a balanced key lime filling topped with whipped cream cheese and a citrus glaze.

• Southern Custard (Buttermilk)

  $34.50

  A smooth, mild, and sweet pie with a filling described as a cross between chess pie and a sugar cookie, served in a signature crust.

• Gluten-Free Pies

  Available in select flavors, these gluten-free pies are noted for their delicious taste and are a welcome option for those with dietary restrictions.

Perfect For

• casual dining
• dessert
• celebration