Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

About Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is a bakery located in Colleyville, Texas, specializing in pies. They offer a variety of flavors in both 4-inch and 9-inch sizes, as well as mini pie assortments. Popular options include chocolate cream, key lime, pecan, and apple pies. The shop also offers cookies and other baked goods. They provide catering and delivery services, making them a convenient option for events or everyday treats. The establishment is women-owned and has received a health score of 96.

The Vibe

This pie shop offers a casual and family-friendly atmosphere. The decor is often described as cute and whimsical. Service is generally noted as friendly and attentive, with staff providing helpful recommendations. While some reviews mention inconsistencies in customer service, the overall sentiment points towards a welcoming environment for enjoying sweet treats. It's a place suited for quick stops, family outings, or picking up desserts for gatherings.

• casual
• family friendly
• cozy
• neighborhood spot

What's Good

• 4” chocolate cream

  $11.05

  Rich chocolate custard in an Oreo crust, topped with fresh whipped cream and chocolate shavings.

• 4” key lime

  $11.05

  A balanced key lime filling in a graham cracker crust, finished with whipped cream cheese and citrus glaze.

• 4” pecan

  $11.05

  Toasted pecans in a gooey filling, served in a buttery shortbread crust, a classic Southern dessert.

• granny's apple (9")

  $41.60

  Crisp Granny Smith apples with sugar and spice, baked into a buttery crust and topped with house-made apple crumble.

• i-40 (9")

  $41.60

  A rich pie featuring pecans, chocolate chips, and a creamy filling, offering a blend of textures.

Perfect For

• dessert
• celebration
• casual dining
• takeout