Buttermilk Sky Pie

About Buttermilk Sky Pie

Buttermilk Sky Pie is a bakery located in Mansfield, TX, specializing in pies. They offer a variety of flavors in both 4-inch personal sizes and 9-inch family sizes. Popular options include Key Lime, I-40 (pecan and chocolate chip), Nanny's Pecan, and Peanut Butter Cream. The bakery also offers gluten-friendly versions of some of its pies and a selection of cookies. They provide dine-in, take-out, and delivery services, making their pies accessible for various occasions.

The Vibe

The atmosphere at Buttermilk Sky Pie is generally described as friendly and cozy, with staff often noted for their helpfulness and pleasant demeanor. It's a place suited for casual visits, picking up treats, or enjoying a sweet moment. While some reviews mention it being quiet, others highlight a welcoming environment. It caters well to families and individuals looking for a sweet indulgence.

• casual
• friendly
• cozy
• family friendly

What's Good

• 4" Key Lime

  A popular choice, noted for a good balance of tartness and a well-made graham cracker crust.

• 4" I-40

  This pie combines pecan and chocolate, offering a blend of flavors that some find appealing, though the chocolate can be a point of preference.

• 4" Nanny's Pecan

  Frequently praised as one of the best pecan pies, with a rich flavor and satisfying texture.

• 4" Peanut Butter Cream

  Described as creamy and not overly rich, this pie is a favorite for peanut butter lovers.

• Cloud Cookies

  These cookies are mentioned as a fresh and delicious alternative or accompaniment to the pies.

Perfect For

• casual dining
• dessert
• celebration
• take out