Big Italy Pizzeria

About Big Italy Pizzeria

Big Italy Pizzeria is a pizza restaurant located in Medford, NY. The establishment offers a variety of pizzas, including specialty pies like the BBQ Chicken Pie and Grandma Pie, alongside classic options such as Margherita and Sicilian. The menu also features appetizers like chicken wings and meatballs, as well as pasta dishes. Reviews frequently highlight the large slice sizes and the unique, nostalgic decor. The restaurant is known for its friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere that aims to provide a classic New York pizza experience.

The Vibe

Big Italy Pizzeria offers a distinctive atmosphere characterized by its quirky and nostalgic decor, including a train set on the ceiling and various memorabilia. The space is described as small and cozy, with limited seating but a high level of hospitality. Service is consistently noted as friendly and efficient, with staff often going the extra mile for customers. This creates a welcoming environment suitable for families and casual diners seeking a comfortable, unpretentious meal.

• cozy
• quirky
• family friendly
• nostalgic

What's Good

• Grandma Pie

  $25.95

  A house special pizza, frequently praised for its sauce and large size, often cited as a standout item.

• Brooklyn Pizza

  $32.95

  Features cheese on the bottom and sauce on top, a style that reviewers compare favorably to authentic Brooklyn pizza.

• Chicken Wings

  $11.95

  Available in regular, Buffalo, or BBQ sauce, these are noted as homemade and very good by some patrons.

• Pie Sampler

  $21.95

  Allows customers to choose any four slices, offering a way to try multiple pizza varieties.

• Gluten Free Pizza

  $19.50

  A gluten-free option with classic cheese, catering to dietary needs.

Perfect For

• casual dining
• family meal
• quick bite